I'll preface this review by saying that I am a "Street Fighter II" fan, that I love fighting
games, and that previously my only exposure to this film was to the heavily Americanized
version that clocks a couple minutes shorter.
First and foremost, I recommend the film in either its American or Japanese versions. I mean,
I'm not saying it's any damn good, but if you love "Street Fighter" games and for some odd
reason have still never seen this movie, it's totally worth picking up, as games made after
this film actually go back and use plot points from it.
Like I said before, I'd really only been exposed to the American version, so I was really keen
to see the Japanese one. The dialogue in the American one is cornball as fuck, the voice acting
ranging from competent to dreadful, the dubbing job atrocious, and the soundtrack comprised
entirely of popular and popular-style music as opposed to the more traditional score used in
the Japanese film. As a result, the American one is a stupid good time, and now, having seen
the Japanese one I can say with certainty that honestly, Americans weren't missing out as much
as they think they were.
First, if you picked up the unrated American version of Street Fighter II: The Animated
Movie, you pretty much got the whole movie. A couple of gratuitous shots of Chun-Li in the
shower are cut or trimmed, and I think a little bloodshed might be missing, but other than that
it's really the same damn movie as the Japanese one. So if you're looking for new visual
content, you're barking up the wrong tree.
Where the Japanese version murders the crap out of the American one, though, is the dialogue.
Here, the characters all exhibit more careful, measured language than they did in the souped up
American version. Lines don't seem silly anymore, conversations aren't awkward, and it actually
composes a fairly well-written movie, at least where video game adaptations are concerned. It
stays very true to the threadbare plotting of the video games, and its characters are developed
logically. While the American version tells the same basic story, its tarted up dialogue and
shoddy voice acting really don't do it justice.
The flipside is in the soundtrack. The Japanese film's soundtrack is really pedestrian and
generic, and I hate to say it, but the pop influenced American track, engineered for teen males
aged 12-29, really fits the film better in places and gives it the oomph it needs. The Japanese
music is good for helping the plot, but it really guts the action sequences, which are actually
some of the best I've seen in an anime. One, in particular, remains my favorite anime fight
scene of all time.
That scene is the fight between Chun-Li and Balrog (Vega in the United States). I've only seen
the movie itself a few times, but that scene has been watched hundreds of times, at least in
the American release. The use of "Ultra" by KMFDM in the background helps elevate the scene
from what it essentially is (Balrog attempting to rape and murder Chun-Li) to the grandiose,
over-the-top bloodfest tour de force that I've come to know and love. It adds force and
intensity to the fight, bringing Chun-Li from a hapless victim with only enough fighting skill
to defend herself to someone who has merely been caught off guard but is nonetheless a
legitimate threat. This is also one of the few scenes in the film where the English dub
outshines the Japanese. When Chun-Li mangles Balrog's face, the Japanese dialogue is
essentially "I'll kill you!" In, the American version, his lines are a lot better:
"My face...my beautiful face is ruined! You bitch, I'll make you suffer!"
The whole thing just gels a lot better and it's almost exclusively this scene that makes me
recommend the American version over the Japanese. It demonstrates just how crucial a good
soundtrack can be to making a film work. If only so much attention had been paid to the rest of
the English script, and better actors had been cast, the American version would completely
dwarf the Japanese one.
All that said, any way you can get it, this is a cool movie. Not a good movie, just a cool one.
But for those of us who'd been jonesing for the Japanese version, be it out of curiosity or a
belief that it would be vastly improved, well...it's not the winner we hoped it would be. The
fighting sequences are lower key (Fei-Long vs. Ryu is about the only one that feels better in
the Japanese film) while the writing and dialogue is superior. In an action movie, though, the
key ingredient is action, and that's why I'd suggest that if you want to see this movie, stick
to the American one.
- Dustin Sklavos |